- To reward on merit is to assume an equal distribution of skill
- Failure in merit is to imply they did not try hard enough
- Technocratic leadership removes moral; the technical aspects dictate choices and decisions
- Merit is important to efficiency
- Meritocracy allows us to believe we get what we deserve
- The protestants celebrated that we were predestined and focused on manifesting their election through their intense work
- Belief in Providence became spiritual sanctions for the status quo
- Wealth is the confluence of personal effort and providential benefit
- “Right side of history” is a moral call that assumes that history is an unbiased telling of events, not a narrative written by the victor, and is used to supplant the notion of Providence
- “America is great because America is good”
- If I am successful because of my work then others have failed because their lack of work
- “Markets give people what they deserve”
- Meritocracy leads to a sense of deserving things
- “Credentialism: the last acceptable prejudice”
- “Smart” is the merit based replacement for moral (much like “right side of history”)
- Incentivizing side-steps governance and persuasion
- Persuasion is critical to democratic processes
- Education is not the problem (people who are more scientifically literate are more likely to have polarized views on climate change)
- An aristocracy dismisses the illusion that the successful deserve their status; workers do not disparage themselves because they were not able to succeed
- If I do not deserve benefit from my birth, then why would I deserve benefit from my talents
- Wages are not rewards for character or merit but rather economic value
- Equal opportunity does make things just because of the unequal distribution in abilities
- Economic value is not the same as moral values
- Education for the past two century have been focused on “sorting” the population based on intelligence
- Colleges tend to consolidate privilege and not provide opportunity
- We should focus on repairing the conditioning from which people want to flee rather than just enabling their movement
Author: Daniel
-
“The Tyranny of Merit” by Michael J Sandel
-
“Think Again” by Adam Grant
- People adapt, not companies
- We have three thinking modes: preacher, prosecutor, politician
- Mental power is not the same as mental dexterity
- People with high IQs tend to be able to identify patterns very quickly and thus fall into stereotyping very quickly
- Those who lack competence tend to have the most confidence, this is the Dunning-Kruger effect
- Experience is different than expertise
- Humility is to be grounded and understand that what you can achieve is different than understanding your skills
- We should be confident in our skills but humble in understanding the problem we are trying to solve
- Imposters tend to work harder and smarter because they have something to prove
- We need to detach our past-self from our present-self
- We need to also detach our identity from our opinions
- The most accurate forecasters reassess their predictions 3-4 times
- When you make a prediction, make a list of conditions that would make you change your mind
- Relationship conflict is bad for productivity; Task conflict is great for decision making
- Agreeable people are good for support
- Disagreeable people are good for rethinking
- Be careful of drowning out the quiet voices
- Starting with, “Can we debate?” is helpful to keep emotions out
- Focus on How not Why
- Fewer facts make a stronger case… If some facts can be dismissed then it is easier to dismiss the whole case
- Try examining a Strong Man, the benefits of their strongest argument
- Conversations about the conversation help sidestep emotional entanglements and can diffuse stubbornness
- Counter factual thinking can help build empathy for alternative viewpoints
- Imagine if you had been born in a different month and had a different sign and were discriminated against because you were born in a different month; how would you feel?
- “Ada-bra-ka-da-bra” is Hebrew for “I create as I speak”
- Sympathy often works better than attempting to fix things
- Boiling things down to two conflicting points encourages entrenchment
- Complexity is a signal of reality of credibility
- Ask your boss, “What are you working to improve right now?”
- Safety and accountability are important
- Focus on the outcome and process
- Commitment Escalation is a leading cause of preventable failures

dunning-kruger-effect_15d723a27fe7e950f1786e9505e968e0_2000.jpg (1920×1080) (umarbahadoor.com) -
“Salt: A World History” by Mark Kurlansky
- Chinese were the first to mine salt
- Gunpowder is made from salt
- Egyptian tombs have two parts, the below ground burial and an above ground offering
- Proteins unravel in the presence of heat, salt
- Salt mines shift under their weight and close their own cracks as brine fills and dries
- The Celtic economy was based on salt
- “Common salts” is a Roman idiom
- Curing fish enabled mass distribution of fish and people who could eat fish rations
- Milk curdles under contact with animal skin, especially the stomach
- Fat resists salt which is why oily fish need to be salted more and pressed
-
“Never Split the Difference” by Chris Voss
- Ask open-ended questions to retain control and divert attention
- “How can I do that?”
- Fast, emotional thinking informs and guides our slower, rational response
- Assumptions blind, hypothesis guide
- Make yourself unimportant to the negotiations
- Cognitive bias is focused on making a coherent story, not gathering information
- Focus on listening to their wants, needs, and aspirations
- Slow the conversation down
- Generally you want the playful voice but sometimes late-night-dj
- Repeat the last three words they said
- To calm aggression
- Use the late night DJ voice
- Start with “sorry”
- Mirror
- Silence, at least 4 seconds
- Negotiating should be a discovery not a contest
- Label feelings with, “It seems like…”
- Clear the road before advertising the destination
- Getting a “no” helps you clarify things
- People have a need to say “No” to feel in control so get them to say it early
- “Is now a bad time?” is good to ask
- “Have you given up on this project?” is like walking away from the stubborn child who refuses to leave the park
- The goal is to help them feel safe, secure, and in control
- “Yes” is often an escape route
- “That’s right” is gold, “You’re right” is death
- Be careful of compromise, it often leaves both side unhappy and turns out a worse outcome
- No deal is better than a bad deal
- When assessing a threat, look for answers to who, what, when, where
- “What does it take to be successful here?”
- “How am I supposed to do that?” asks the other party to help and while helping them feel in control
- The other side always has a team… Make sure you are engaging everyone on that team
- “Yes” is nothing without “how”
- “How will we accomplish our contract?”
- “How do we know we are on-track?”
- “How will we know when we are off-track?”
- People who can break the deal are often more critical than the deal maker
- There are assertive, accommodating, and analytical people
- Analysts
- Want time to think before responding; they value precision in their responses so try to can consider all the angles
- Do not care for human interactions
- Expect equity in anything given
- Accommodators
- Love social interaction and seek engagement
- Do not necessarily need reciprocity
- Takes silence to mean anger
- Assertives
- Need to feel heard before they can listen
- Value victories
- Takes silence as an invitation to keep talking
- Give them an inch and they will go a mile
- Analysts
- The golden rule is wrong here (and most places): Treat other how they want to be treated
- Focus on the issues not the person
- It is good to hit the pause button when things are not going well
- Decreasing concessions ending are ideal:
- Set an extreme anchor
- Close the gap between the anchor are your real number by half
- If needed, close by a quarter
- End on an exact, non-round number to make it feel like you are at your end
- Look for the “black swans” (the hidden motivations behind the negotiator’s behavior)
- Leverage is having something the only side wants
- Look for their “religion”: the beliefs that drive them to action
- “They’re crazy” is our way for saying, “They do not make sense”
- One side has information the other does not
- They have a constraint they do not want to share
- Ask open-ended questions to retain control and divert attention
-
“How to Talk so Little Kids Will Listen” by Joanna Faber and Julie King
- We cannot act right when we do not feel right
- Put their feeling into a word then use that word in a sentence
- Good feelings cannot come in until the bad feelings are acknowledge and let out
- Often, trying to “fix things” is about protecting ourselves from the feelings of others
- Just accept the darn emotion!
- “‘But’ takes away the gift you have just given”; use something like “The problem is…” or “Even though you know…” instead
- Acknowledge their desires in writing or drawings
- Match your tone with emotion
- Help them fantasize what they want but should not have (“If you could have cake for dinner, what kind would you have?”)
- Try leading with a statement instead of a question
- “Please” should be reserved for actual requests
- Offer choices
- Think about how to put the children in charge… With restraints.
- Use a gesture or word (noun) to remind instead of bossing around
- Appreciate the progress you see before pointing out the deficiencies
- Act without insult
- Actions are for protection, not for punishment
- Try to make amends, not apologies, instead of punishments (“Your sister was hurt when you pushed her. What can we do to help her feel better?”)
- Problem solving
- Acknowledge their feelings first
- Briefly describe your feelings
- Ask for, and write down all ideas
- Decide the ideas that you both agree on
- Try out the solutions, double check the plan with your child
- Rewards are offered with an implied threat
- We are driven by a sense of autonomy, competency or mastery, and purpose
- Praise that evaluates sounds dismissive or dubious
- It is not always appropriate to praise, consider asking questions or starting a conversation instead
- Describe what you see regarding effort and progress instead of evaluating
- Instead of praising behavior, describe the affect the behavior has on others
- Try to avoid being proud (because it implies you did the work, not them) and comparisons to others
- When they are discouraged, acknowledge their feelings and offer a new picture of themselves they can work towards
- Quietly move to their level
- Do not expect consistency in usage of new skills
- (So much of raising kids well seems to be focused on helping them make sense of the patterns of the world)
- Tell them what they can do instead of what they cannot, they may understand the words but not the context
- Everyone wants to feel understood, act autonomously, be competent
- Acknowledge the facts instead of asking obvious questions
- Lying is a natural stage of development, guide them to being truth telling
- All feeling are acceptable; some actions must be limited
- We will not be calm and in control all the time, neither will they
- Try telling the story of what happened